CLIMATE / Analysis

Carbon Capture: Science or Distraction?

What carbon capture and storage can and cannot do, what it costs, and why scientists disagree about its role in reaching net zero.

climaRevolt
climaRevolt ExpertsWritten and checked by our specialists · Updated 11 October 2026
10 min read
Carbon Capture: Science or Distraction?

No climate technology divides the room like carbon capture. To its champions, it is the indispensable tool for the emissions we cannot avoid (cement, steel, aviation) and the only way to claw back the carbon we have already released. To its critics, it is a fossil-fuel industry alibi: perpetually five years away, chronically over-budget, and politically useful precisely because it delays the harder work of phasing out combustion.

Both camps are arguing from evidence. The question is which evidence matters most.

What the numbers say

Today, roughly 45 commercial facilities capture about 50 million tonnes of CO₂ per year: around 0.1% of global emissions. Announced projects would raise that to over 400 million tonnes by 2030, but announcement is not construction: historically, most proposed capture projects have been cancelled or indefinitely delayed, and several flagship plants have underperformed their capture targets by wide margins.

~0.1%

of global emissions captured today

$600–1,000

per tonne for direct air capture

6 Gt

annual removal some 1.5°C paths assume by 2050

Where it makes sense — and where it doesn’t

The strongest case is industrial. Cement chemistry releases CO₂ no matter how clean the kiln’s energy is; capture is one of the few options. The same logic applies to parts of steel, chemicals and waste incineration. The weakest case is retrofitting power plants, where renewables plus storage now beat capture-equipped fossil power on cost almost everywhere.

Direct air capture, pulling CO₂ from ambient air, occupies a category of its own. It is real, it works, and it remains radically expensive. Costs have fallen, but scaling from thousands of tonnes to billions would demand energy and capital on the order of a new global industry.

The competition: renewables plus storage now undercut capture-equipped fossil power almost everywhere.
The competition: renewables plus storage now undercut capture-equipped fossil power almost everywhere.

The honest answer

Every credible pathway to well-below 2°C includes some carbon capture and removal, and none of them include enough to compensate for continued fossil expansion. The technology is a scalpel being marketed, at times, as a bulldozer.

Science or distraction? It is both, depending entirely on who is holding it and what they are using it to justify. The task for policy is to fund the scalpel and refuse the alibi.

What is carbon capture and storage (CCS)?

Carbon capture and storage separates carbon dioxide from the exhaust of a power plant or factory, compresses it, and pumps it deep underground into rock formations where it can be stored for thousands of years. When the captured CO₂ is used to make products or, controversially, to push more oil out of old wells, it is called carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS).

What is direct air capture?

Direct air capture (DAC) pulls CO₂ straight out of the open air using large fans and chemical filters, then stores it underground or uses it. Because CO₂ is very dilute in air, DAC needs much more energy than capturing it from a smokestack. Early plants operate in Iceland (Climeworks), and larger projects are being built in the United States. Today it costs several hundred dollars per tonne, far more than most emission cuts.

Carbon capture vs carbon removal

These are often confused. Capturing CO₂ from a cement plant stops new emissions from reaching the air, but does not reduce what is already there. Carbon removal, such as direct air capture with storage, reforestation or bioenergy with capture, takes CO₂ out of the atmosphere. Climate models need both, but removal is the only way to reverse past emissions.

Does carbon capture really work?

The technology works: CO₂ has been captured and stored for decades. The problems are cost, scale and track record. Several flagship projects have captured far less than promised, and most captured CO₂ to date has been used for enhanced oil recovery. Projects deserve support where emissions are hard to avoid, but measured honestly and never as a reason to delay cutting emissions. For the businesses measuring their own footprint, see how Scope 3 emissions are counted.

Frequently asked questions

What is carbon capture and storage?

A process that captures CO₂ from industrial or power-plant exhaust and stores it deep underground in rock formations.

What is direct air capture?

Technology that removes CO₂ directly from the air with fans and chemical filters; it works but currently costs several hundred dollars per tonne.

Is carbon capture good or bad for the climate?

Useful for hard-to-avoid industrial emissions and carbon removal, but harmful if it is used to justify continued fossil fuel expansion.

THE CLIMAREVOLT WEEKLY

Get the climate stories that matter, explained, every Sunday.

One email a week: new explainers, data and free tools. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

ShareXLi